Battle: Dumbledore Vs Voldemort
What if Dumbledore and Voldemort dueled 1 vs 1 without their familiars i.e Fawkes and Nagini, who'd win?
Round 1: Voldemort vs Prime Dumbledore (the one who defeated Grindelwald without Elder Wand)
Round 2: Voldemort vs Dumbledore with Elder Wand
Round 3: Voldemort vs Dumbledore without Elder Wand
Edit: Voldemort's other horcrux are not considered as this is 1 vs 1 duel, so technically Voldemort can still return if he's killed by Dumbledore but it'd be still counted as defeat for Voldemort
Hm, I think in all cases Voldemort has the advantage of the horcruxes so he can't actually be defeated unless we are talking about a Dumbledore who has already figured out Tom's secret and taken care of it.
But then again, Voldemort feared Dumbledore. My guess is, Dumbledore with the Elder Wand and in good health would win.
I don't even know if the Elder Wand plays such a big role, Dumbledore is a capable and experienced wizard and I imagine that he is powerful regardless of the wand he holds as long as he is in good health.
Voldemort's killing curse would likely have hit Dumbledore if it wasn't for Fawkes in OOTP, so I would think Voldemort wins. If Dumbledore also aimed to kill, perhaps it would be different ... but I don't think he would.
